See more of Five Pennies Creamery on Facebook. Log In. Forgot account? or. Create New Account. Not Now. Five Pennies Creamery. Ice Cream Shop in Rockville Centre, New York. 4. 8. 4. 8 out of 5 stars. Closes in 60 minutes. Community See All. 2, 878 people like this. 2, 910 people follow this. About See All. 11 N Park Ave (2, 285. 01 mi)